Texas has its own independent dispute resolution (IDR) system, created by Senate Bill 1264 and run by the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI). It applies to care received on or after January 1, 2020. For claims under state-regulated plans, it is the process to use, not federal IDR.
At a glance
| Arbitration | Mediation | |
|---|---|---|
| Who uses it | Out-of-network providers (not facilities) | Out-of-network facilities |
| Request window | 20 to 90 days after receiving the first claim payment | 20 to 180 days after receiving the first claim payment |
| Informal settlement | First 30 days | First 30 days |
| Outcome | Binding award by day 51 | Mediation conference by day 180 |
| Cost | Arbitrator’s fixed fee, split equally | Mediator’s fixed fee, split equally |
Which plans are covered
Texas IDR applies to:
- State-regulated insurance plans (HMOs and preferred or exclusive provider plans). Their ID cards show “DOI” or “TDI”.
- Employees Retirement System of Texas coverage, such as HealthSelect.
- Teacher Retirement System of Texas coverage (TRS-ActiveCare and TRS-Care).
- Higher-education health plans offered under Insurance Code Chapter 1683, added in 2025. Requests must identify the plan type as “Higher Ed Plan”.
- Self-funded ERISA plans that opt in. Since legislation passed in 2023, self-funded plans can opt in to the Texas process one year at a time. TDI lists the plans that have opted in.
It does not apply to self-funded plans that haven’t opted in, or to Medicare. Those claims typically go to the federal IDR process.
Which providers and services
The law protects patients with state-regulated plans from balance billing for emergency care, and for care at in-network facilities when the patient didn’t choose the provider. Examples include an anesthesiologist assigned to a surgery, or a radiologist reading an MRI. Covered provider types include emergency care, facility-based, diagnostic imaging and laboratory providers.
If a patient chooses an out-of-network provider at an in-network facility, the provider may balance bill only with a signed waiver obtained at least 10 business days before the procedure.
The arbitration timeline
- Request (day 0). File through the Texas IDR portal between 20 and 90 days after you receive the first claim payment. A zero-dollar initial payment, for example when the allowed amount went to the deductible, still counts as the first payment.
- Days 1–30: informal settlement. The parties can settle or agree on an arbitrator.
- Day 31. The portal assigns an arbitrator if the parties haven’t agreed on one.
- Days 31–51. The arbitrator requests and reviews information from both sides.
- Day 51. The arbitrator issues a binding award and reports it to TDI.
- Payment. The health plan records payment in the portal within 30 days.
Multiple claims with the same plan can be combined into a single arbitration request. TDI’s provider FAQ describes a cap of $5,000 in total per request.
How Texas arbitrators decide
Texas isn’t pure baseball-style arbitration. The arbitrator first determines a reasonable amount using 10 statutory factors. These include the provider’s training and experience, the complexity and circumstances of the case, and benchmark data on billed charges and in-network rates in the same area. The arbitrator then selects whichever final offer is closest to that reasonable amount.
The better your offer tracks the evidence on those factors, the more likely it is to be the closer of the two.
Practical takeaways
- Don’t file too early. Requests before day 20 aren’t accepted.
- Don’t file too late. The 90-day window closes firmly. Diary it from the date the first payment is received.
- Check for an opt-in before routing a self-funded claim to the federal process.
- Use the 30-day settlement period. Settlement is the most common outcome in Texas.
Sources
- TDI: What doctors should know about Texas’ surprise billing law
- TDI: FAQ on mediation and arbitration requirements and processes
- TDI: Independent Dispute Resolution Process (October 2025)
General information, not legal advice. Confirm current requirements with TDI before filing.